You and I are like oil and water And we've been trying, trying, trying Oh, to mix it up We've been dancing on a volcano And we've been crying, crying, crying Over blackened souls Babe, this wouldn't be the first time It will not be the last time There is no parasol that could shelter this weather I been smiling with anchors on my shoulders But I've been dying, dying, dying Oh, oh, oh to let them go Babe, this wouldn't be the first time It will not be the last time There is no parasol that could shelter this weather Babe, this wouldn't be the first time It will not be the last time We were trying to believe everything would get better We've been lying to each other Hey babe, let's just call it, call it, call it Oh, what it is Oil and water Oil and water Oil and water